Exit Planning Tools for Business Owners

Exit Options

Quarterbacking is Not Exit Planning

by

Quarterbacking is a popular term when exit planners are talking to clients. It’s supposed to invoke a vision of someone who is in control. Think about a Tom Brady, Aaron Rodgers or Patrick Mahomes standing tall in the pocket, surveying the offense and defense unfolding before him.

There is a real problem with using “Quarterbacking” when referring to your exit planning professional team. The quarterback calls the plays. The job of the rest of the team is to run them as instructed.  I’ve yet to meet a CPA or attorney who thinks that is the best way to develop a client’s exit plan.

Teamwork

Exit planning, like no other form of professional consulting, is a team sport. When I am engaged by a client, I have the responsibility of defending his or her long-term objectives. The other advisors, who may include an insurance agent, financial planner, or appraiser, all have experience to lend to the process.

We can modify a plan multiple times and in many ways. The accountant may have some excellent restructuring ideas to save taxes. The attorney can add terms to a buy/sell agreement to protect the owners from having their equity unfairly valued by the IRS, or from having it pass to parties outside the company.

The insurance agent can mitigate the risk of illness or death derailing the timely transfer of the business, or of the surviving family being left destitute. The appraiser can develop valuations that take advantage of the discounts permitted under IRS guidelines.

Each of these professionals has a role, and should be able to add their skills to the process, with only one exception. They should not be permitted to do anything that interferes with the owner’s objectives. That’s the responsibility of the exit planner.

The Alternative to Quarterbacking

I prefer to think of the exit planner’s role as analogous to that of an orchestra conductor.

quarterbackingThe exit planner may not be as skilled in any specific discipline as the others on the team. He may know something about tax planning, or legal structuring or insurance. She probably knows a bit about valuation and even more about contracts.

But, like the conductor, he or she doesn’t know more about any of those subjects than the advisor who spends full-time in that area.

No one expects the conductor to step off the podium for a violin solo, or to fill in for the French Horn.  In fact, you don’t even want the conductor to tap the triangle for that one little note in the pause. If he did, he would be distracted from his primary role of keeping all the musicians on the same page.

Having one advisor coordinate the contributions of others greatly improves the overall result. Expecting him or her to dictate details outside his area of expertise is foolish. Expect your exit planner to lead without quarterbacking.

John F. Dini, CExP, CEPA is an exit planning coach and the President of MPN Incorporated in San Antonio Texas. He is the publisher of Awake at 2 o’clock, and has authored three books on business ownership.

Why Plan Now? Exit Planning for Small Business

by

Owners ask all the time, “Why Plan Now?” “I’m not planning to leave my business for years. I feel good, and I still enjoy my business. I’m not sure what else I would do. Besides, if my company is only going to sell for two or three times earnings, I can make more than that by sticking around.”

All are valid arguments. Baby Boomers, the youngest of whom turned 55 this year, are working longer and are more active well into their 60s and often into their 70s. The term “next career” describes the growing portion of the population who are choosing another full-time activity after leaving their jobs or businesses.

Why Plan Now?

That said, there are good reasons why every Baby Boomer business owner should have a documented exit plan.

why plan now?

  1. A plan is not an action. As the late, great Yogi Berra said, “If you don’t know where you are going, you may wind up somewhere else.” The process of deciding what your ultimate outcome should be gets you mentally prepared, but implementation only starts when you say so.
  2. It will focus your efforts. Say, for example, you decide that ultimately you want to sell to your employees. Your investments in hiring and training will look very different than if you plan to sell to a large competitor who would shutter your operation.
  3. It will make you a better business owner. Thinking through the things that drive value in your business, (employees, products, and customers,) will inevitable highlight what could be improved. You will look at your business through a buyer’s eyes. That lends a whole new perspective.

The first four parts of this series dealt with various exit scenarios. This is about your timing.

How to Start

There’s a ton of resources both in past articles on this site (indexed by topic) and in our free library of planning tools and educational materials at www.YourExitMap.com. Many Financial Planners, Bankers and CPAs are getting one of the certifications in exit planning (Either the Certified Exit Planning Advisor – CEPA or the Certified Exit Planner- CExP.) That equips them to have a broader conversation that just focusing on their specialty.

Chapters are springing up of professionals who specialize in exit planning. Booth the Exit Planning Exchange (XPX) and the Exit Planning Institute (EPI) regularly offer seminars for owners considering their exit strategy, Between the two there are chapters in about 40 US cities.

Try putting the term “Exit Planning” in an Amazon book search. You’ll have a choice of about 25 titles.

Finally, there’s my standard (if somewhat cliched) answer to the question “Why plan now?”

Because sooner or later, every owner leaves his or her business, whether voluntarily or otherwise. It’s only the biggest financial event of your life.

John F. Dini, CExP, CEPA is an exit planning coach and the President of MPN Incorporated in San Antonio Texas. He has authored three books on business ownership.

Selling to Employees: Exit Planning for Small Business Part 4

by

Selling to employees is one method of transition that is growing rapidly in popularity. Usually the  driving motivation is a desire to help the people who got you this far enjoy some of the benefits of ownership, but there is a substantial list of other benefits.

  1. Pricing is agreed at the start, not in adversarial negotiations.
  2. Valuation is flexible. The business can be sold for more or less than its Fair Market Value, as long as both sides agree and cash flow supports it.
  3. The legacy of the business lives on in the community.
  4. Where there are substantial challenges to an outside buyer, such as industries whpiere work goes to the lowest bidder, employees are more confident that they can succeed in the system.
  5. Financing is built into the transition plan.

(By the way, if you are just picking up this series now, prior topics included strategies that aren’t suited to small business, selling to a third party, and selling to family.)

“But they have no money!”

That’s the most frequent objection when we suggest an employee sale, but it is easily remedied by time. In fact, time and risk are corollaries. The more time you have, the less risk you’ll take. Faster is riskier.

At one end of the spectrum we’ll say you want to exit the business in the next thirty to sixty days. That’s probably enough time to draw up a purchase agreement and transfer ownership. The payment for the business would be entirely in an installment note from your workers. Rapid exit, but maximum probability that you will never see the entire purchase price.

On the other hand, what if you have five to ten years for selling to employees?  You could sell stock for a note, and let employees pay for their shares with bonuses based on increasing profitability. They are motivated to grow the company, while you continue to receive all the profits you were due anyway.

As they increase their ownership, they can qualify for lender financing to purchase your equity. Done well, and with enough time, you can realize the full value of the business and increase your short-term income along the way. Time gives you lower risk, and the potential for higher reward.

Are they qualified?

That is another question entirely and one that depends largely on you. If you’ve hired the right people and trained them well, selling to employees is a breeze. If you are the center of everything that happens in your business, it could be a problem.

Remember, the more you work in your business the less it is worth. To see how dependent your business is on you, take the quiz at www.ownercentricity.com.

What if they are willing and able, but not ready? Or perhaps you have a few key managers, but they lack some critical skill sets? Again, time gives you the flexibility to deal with those issues.

You may not have anyone who could ever run the business. Again, with suffcient time, you can “hire your buyer.” I’ve seen businesses where an owner used the promise of ownership to recruit someone whom he’d never attract otherwise.

Selling to employees is the ultimate exit plan in your level of control over the process, determining how much you want from the transaction, and choosing your date of departure. If you haven’t considered it in your list of options, you might want to think again.

New! The affordable exit planning system for small business. 9 modules, 9 online tools and completion in 90 days. Take a look at ExitMap® Express!

Family Succession: Exiting a Small Business Part 3

by

It’s time to discuss family succession. In Part One of this series we looked at exit strategies that aren’t really available to small businesses, and in Part Two we discussed selling to a third party. Now let’s talk about the issues when transferring to a family member or members.

Which Kids?

When passing the business to family, often the primary issue is inheritance. Small business owners frequently have 50%, 60% or as much as 80% of their personal net worth in their company. There is a temptation to treat the business like any other personal asset, and divide it among all the children.
dinner
“After all,” (the logic goes,) “We built this for our family’s security. It isn’t fair that only the kids who work in the business should benefit.”Sometimes the non-active children have succeeded in lucrative careers, like medicine or law. That may make an asymmetrical legacy easier.

Other times the children outside the business have not been successful at all. They are the ones who most need support, and in fact may be on the payroll already (although not “active” in any meaningful sense.) Parents’ expect the same unconditional love they have for them from their siblings, but it just doesn’t work that way.

Splitting it “Fairly”

When the company is too valuable an asset to balance inheritance with other assets, we recommend passing some to the active children before your death. That can be via sale, bonus or gifting, but it recognizes the active children’s contribution to the business.

Upon death, you can divide the balance of the equity evenly, but with a contract that says the non-active children must immediately sell their shares to the active ones at Fair Market Value. This accomplishes several things:

  1. The value of the business at the parents’ death  is divided “evenly.”
  2. The non-active kids get the step-up in basis, and should have no tax on the sale.
  3. The active kids retain 100% of the benefits from their efforts going forward.

Its especially important to get spouse signatures on these agreements. Valuations and agreements between family are fine, but an outsider (especially an ex-spouse) may not be as amenable.

I have a comment that I use with parents who are deciding how to divide ownership among children. “In the long run, you want everyone to still have a nice Thanksgiving together.”

Securing Family Succession

This is the other big issue. The parent wants family ownership to be their legacy, but their child or children aren’t qualified to run it. There is capable management, but none of them have the same last name.

Remember, we are talking about small business in this series. Families named Cargill, Ford or Walton need not be too concerned  about non-family management.

But for a small company, you can’t put children in a position where the resignation of a key employee could sink the whole enterprise. That makes the children subject to blackmail. Key operating skills have to be retained with incentives.

You don’t need to make key employees into partners, but they should have a vested interest in growth and profitability. This can be as simple as bonuses for company performance, but long-term retention usually requires non-qualifed deferred compensation (NQDC) plans.

These are tied to the long-term growth and profitability of the business. “Non-qualified” simply means it isn’t an ERISA-qualified benefit (like an IRA or 401K) because it is discriminatory in nature.

There are a number of forms for NQDC, mostly involving virtual equity. Phantom stock, stiock options, stock appreciation rights and warrants are all avenues for such compensation. They allow an employee to amass an increasing nest egg over time, based on tenure and appreciation in the value of the business.

Da Plan! Da Plan!

Whether you are deciding how to apportion the business for your estate, securing continuation of a management team, or just minimizing taxes on the transfer, planning is the key. Determining your goals for family succession and working through your options well in advance (5 years or more before your planned retirement,) is the secret for the successful transfer of a family business.

Without planning, you are putting Thanksgiving at risk.

New! The affordable exit planning system for small business. 9 modules, 9 online tools and completion in 90 days. Take a look at ExitMap® Express!

Exiting a Small Business #2 – Selling to a Third Party

by

“In our last episode,” (I’ve always wanted to say that) we discussed the exit paths that are not usually available when exiting a small business. Those are ESOP, Private Equity, and Strategic Acquisition. Now let’s talk about what you can do.

The Realities of Selling to a Third Party

Multiple surveys over the last decade all show the same result. About 85% of small business (5 to 20 employees) owners say that their exit plan is to sell to a third party.

Let’s do the math. There are currently over 3,000,000 small business owners over 55 years old in the USA. We can assume that by the time the youngest is 75, virtually all will have exited their businesses. That means an average of 150,000 businesses a year will transfer or close.

According to the International Business Brokers Association (IBBA), their intermediaries execute about 40,000 transactions a year. It should be a bull market for intermediaries (although not for sellers.) Let’s assign them 50,000 transactions annually.

That leaves 100,000 small businesses a year who will have to find methods of transfer other than through a business broker.

Broker Alternatives

Business Brokers can be cynical about their clients. They commonly complain that the best businesses sell through their accountants, bankers, attorneys, or word of mouth. Their listings consist mostly of the “Dismal Ds,” (Death, Disease, Disaster, Divorce, Declining sales, Dissention among partners, Disinterest, etc.) While this is an exaggeration, it’s true that the better shape your business is in, the more likely it is to sell easily.

If you’ve prepared your business well, understand your potential buyer, and are personally ready to move on, your best bet for selling is probably your business network.

Being Ready

Brokers sell about 20% of the businesses they list. Again, that number has been consistent for decades. According to the Pepperdine Private Capital Markets Report, the number one reason for an intermediary’s failure to sell a business is “unreasonable expectations of value” by the seller.

Again, that may be self-serving, but brokers are paid for success. None would sneer at a higher valuation if he or she could get it. A realistic expectation of value is the first and most important step in a successful sale.

Some brokers will take a listing at any price. They believe that eventually, the market reaction will drive their clients to a reality check. The problem with that approach is that the first buyers, and possibly the most qualified, are driven off by an unreasonable price at the outset. They don’t come back later.

If you plan on selling to a third party, you will be best served by being prepared before you talk to a broker. There are a lot more areas to cover, and this series of articles is just a high-level view of your options. For a more complete approach, you may want to check out my book 11 Things You Absolutely Need to Know about Selling Your Business. The EBook is free for Kindle Unlimited subscribers.

Next up, selling to family members.