Exit Planning Tools for Business Owners

John Dini

Non-Qualified Plans

by

When I talk to business owners about “non-qualified plans,” their first reaction is often “Hold on there. I don’t want to get in trouble!”

The term “Non-qualified” merely refers to the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, more commonly known as ERISA. As the title indicates, it is the basic set of regulations for retirement plans. If your company offers a 401K or SEP IRA, it has a Qualified Plan. If you have an Employee Stock Ownership Plan (ESOP), that is also an ERISA plan.

Under the terms of ERISA, a plan must be made available to all employees. In return, the company can deduct contributions as benefit expenses, and the employee can contribute pretax income to the plan.

A non-qualified plan doesn’t comply with ERISA requirements.  It is discriminatory in nature, meaning it is not offered equally to all employees. The employee cannot make contributions, and the employer usually can’t deduct the costs of funding the plan (which is built around future benefits,) as of current expenses.

Most non-qualified plans are designed as Deferred Compensation, thus the common acronym NQDC. The concept is to offer key employees a carrot for long-term retention. It can be enhanced retirement funding, insurance, or one of many forms of synthetic equity in the business.

Non-qualified Plan Types

We can start with the simplest example of NQDC. If an employee remains with the company until retirement, he or she will receive an additional year’s salary upon retiring. This benefit is not sequestered in a secure account anywhere, it’s just a promise by the company. It’s known as an “unfunded” benefit. There is no annual statement, just a guaranty (typically in writing,) by the business.

Non-qualified plansOften, an NQDC is funded by an insurance policy with a death benefit and an increasing cash value. It is owned by the company, which pays the premiums. At retirement, the employee receives the paid-up policy. This approach has the added benefit of lending confidence to the process, as the employee can see the funding and growth of the future benefit.

Synthetic equity may be stock options, phantom stock, or Stock Appreciation Rights (SARs.) In most forms, it is the right to future compensation based on any increased value of the business. For example, if the business is valued at $2,000,000 today, the employee may be given a contractual right to 10% of the difference in value at the time of retirement. If the company is worth $3,000,000 then, the employee would receive $100,000. ($3,000,000 minus $2,000,000 times 10%.)

Valuation, Vesting, and Forfeiture

Non-qualified plans based on equity should have a formula for valuing the benefit. It may be any financial measure such as revenue, pre-tax profit, or EBITDA. The objective is to make it clear to both parties how the benefit will be measured.

Vesting is an opportunity to be creative. The benefit can vest gradually, or all at once at a specific point in the future. An employee may be able to collect once fully vested or, in the case of synthetic equity, may have the right to “let it ride” for future growth if other conditions are met.

Regardless of how attractive a benefit may be, no employment relationship lasts forever. Pay special attention to how you construct acceleration and forfeiture clauses. Of course, no one wants to pay out to an employee who has been terminated for cause, but the employee deserves some protection against being let go just because a promised benefit has gotten too expensive.

Similarly, provisions for accelerated valuation in the case of a change in ownership are common. You also may want to consider rolling the NQDC into a stay bonus agreement if you sell the business. If there are options on actual stock involved, you will need to determine the handling of them if they could pass into the hands of someone other than the employee. That would be triggered by bankruptcy, divorce, or death.

Benefits of Non-Qualified Plans

As I described in my book Hunting in a Farmer’s World, incentives for employees should match their level of responsibility. Production workers have incentives based on their production. Managers have incentives based on their ability to manage.

Your very best people, the ones you want to stay with you through their entire careers, should be able to participate in the long-term results of their efforts for the company. Non-qualified plans are a way to single them out and emphasize your interest in sharing what you are building together.

As always. check with your tax advisor. Setting a plan up incorrectly could result in unwanted or phantom taxation for the company or the employee.

John F. Dini develops transition and succession strategies that allow business owners to exit their companies on their own schedule, with the proceeds they seek and complete control over the process. He takes a coaching approach to client engagements, focusing on helping owners of companies with $1M to $250M in revenue achieve both their desired lifestyles and legacies.

Are Remote Employees Value Killers?

by

Remote workers, computers, businessesRemote employees can have a dramatic impact on the value of your business. If your exit strategy is to sell to a third party, take some time to think about the areas where offsite workers could have an impact.

Curb Appeal

One of the first things any good business broker will look at is your curb appeal. Your business needs to look good, just like a house that’s for sale. (OK, maybe right now a house doesn’t even need to look good, but you know what I mean.)

When I brokered Main Street businesses, I was always surprised at how much we had to tell owners. Clean up the piles of files in the office. Clean and sweep the parking area. Remove the pile of broken pallets next to the dumpster.

What message does your office space send?  Is it better to downsize, and just describe the employees who are no longer on the premises? Or would a buyer prefer to see a room full of empty desks, so that he knows he could bring them back if he so desired? (But he would also be calculating the wasted rent in his mental cash flow.)

Equating Dollar Value

What are your productivity measurements or KPIs for remote workers? Can you prove that they are worth what you are paying them? How? What level of confidence can a new owner have that he is acquiring a productive team? A recent survey in the U.K showed that almost 30% of remote employees were working a side gig on company time.

How is their remote presentation? Unless they are in a job that is strictly production-based, most will interact with customers, vendors or other employees. Do you have standards for their workspace and their appearance on video?

Can you give a buyer confidence in their compensation structure? New ownership can be a great time to ask for a raise. What assurances are there that it won’t happen? As I wrote a few weeks ago, how do you integrate them into your culture?

Confidentiality and Human Resources

Confidentiality about the transaction is more difficult. Does the buyer interview remote employees one by one? You can be sure they are talking to each other, whether on Teams or Slack or just texting each others’ cell phones.

On the other hand, a group video call raises new issues. A buyer could come out of it with a poor impression because one individual is obnoxious or inattentive. Someone might press for inappropriate information. (“Will all of us keep our jobs?”)

Remote Employees Increase  Risk

I am not campaigning against remote employees. They are a fact of life, now and likely for the foreseeable future. I’m just pointing out that handling their management, controlling the information flow to them, and anticipating their potential impact have all become part of exit planning.

The best surprise is no surprise. Part of your planning process when listing your company for sale should be how you will handle these questions.

John F. Dini develops transition and succession strategies that allow business owners to exit their companies on their own schedule, with the proceeds they seek and complete control over the process. He takes a coaching approach to client engagements, focusing on helping owners of companies with $1M to $250M in revenue achieve both their desired lifestyles and legacies.

Internal Leaders Affect the Value of Your Business

by

Internal leaders may not be obvious. They may not even have a “leadership” title. Make no mistake, however; internal leaders are critical to value and attractiveness when it comes to selling your business.

In Super Bowl 55 we saw the impact of an internal leader. Tom Brady has the highest winning percentage of any single athlete in major professional sports. The Tampa Bay Buccaneers have (or at least did up until this season,) the worst win/loss record over their entire existence of any major professional sports team. Yet one man changed the culture of the organization almost overnight.

Remember, for all the accolades being heaped on Brady, he is an employee. He doesn’t own the Buccaneer enterprise or negotiates any contracts other than his own. He didn’t choose the team’s logo, uniforms, location, or coaches.

Tom Brady is paid to fill only one of 53 player positions in the organization. There are also 31 coaches on the team, whose jobs are to teach and give direction to those 53 players. Although every player will acknowledge that winning is a team effort, none will argue the impact of one strong internal leader on his 83 coworkers.

Internal leaders can be good or bad

When I was a very young business owner, I hired an experienced salesman. He was an alcoholic and began inviting other employees to his house for a cocktail after work. It took me some time (too long) to realize that he was plying his coworkers with free booze while he ranted daily about how poorly the company was being run.

I couldn’t understand why there was so much resentment among my team. They seemed to resist any direction I gave them. Finally, one person was kind enough to explain to me what was happening. Because this salesman was my top producer, I was afraid of the impact on revenues if I fired him.

He didn’t want my job. In fact, he didn’t want any of the responsibility that should go with leading. He had merely discovered one of the biggest truths about leadership. It’s easier to tear something down than build it up. People love to hear that things could be better. It’s making them better that is the tough part.

Tom Brady made the Tampa Bay Buccaneers better. Like any good internal leader, he didn’t limit his contribution to his job description as Quarterback. He helped recruit and train the people around him to build a better team.

Identify your internal leaders

An army dispatches its troops under the leadership of its lieutenants, but it succeeds on the ability of its sergeants. As a business owner, you can inspire with core values and set great goals. Whether you reach them, however, will be determined by your internal leaders.

When it comes time for your transition, they are more important than ever. If you are selling to family or employees, they may not expect to be included in equity, but they will determine the acceptance of those who are.

If you are selling to a third party, his or her achievements following the sale are conditional on the support of your internal leaders. They can prop up an inexperienced owner, or sink him without a trace.

If any part of your proceeds from exiting depend on the continued success of the business, you would be wise to identify your internal leaders and make some provision for their continued loyalty after you are gone. If they don’t buy-in, you could see the value of your enterprise (and your payout) decline substantially.

John F. Dini develops transition and succession strategies that allow business owners to exit their companies on their own schedule, with the proceeds they seek and complete control over the process. He takes a coaching approach to client engagements, focusing on helping owners of companies with $1M to $250M in revenue achieve both their desired lifestyles and legacies.

The Coaching Skill in Exit Planning

by

The single most important talent in your exit planning team is coaching skill. I’ve written often in this space about the need for multiple talents, from taxation to legal, financial planning, and risk management. None, however, is more important than coaching.

Let me put it this way. Your planning team can be led from any position, as long as the person leading has coaching skill. If he or she doesn’t, all the clever tax advice or ironclad documentation in the world won’t lead to your successful transition. But if the person leading the team is an experienced coach, you’ll probably be okay.

What is Coaching Skill?

Let’s make it simple. Coaching is asking questions. An experienced coach will ask the questions that no one else does, preferably in a way that doesn’t offend.

Do you want to save money on taxes? Of course, and that should be apparent to every professional involved. Do you want to maintain control until you are paid what the company is worth? Sure. Do you want to ensure that your family is taken care of? Naturally.

These aren’t the questions that derail a transition plan. Here are a few that, left unasked, will.

Is there something more important to you than the proceeds from selling? Is there a part of your legacy that must be preserved if at all possible? Are there non-financial or non-equity stakeholders whose welfare must figure into the plan? Is your family on board with this?

These are the questions that an advisor who is focused on the technical complexities of exiting will often omit.

The Most Important Question

What will you do when you no longer own this business?

For many entrepreneurs, that’s the stumper. Unless you can answer it comfortably, your plan is very likely to fail. Most advisors will ask it in a casual way. “So what will you do next?” They may react little or not at all if your response is “I don’t know.”

When I was active as a business broker, I would decline a listing if an owner couldn’t enunciate a plan for life after the business. In my first book, 11 Things You Absolutely Need to Know about Selling Your Business, I describe a case where an owner declined two offers, each for twice his company’s estimated value. He simply didn’t know what he would do next.

“I don’t know” is a signal that the owner can’t envision life without the activity of the business.

Sometimes the answer is too facile. “I’ll play a lot more golf!” Nice try, but I’ve heard many a retiring owner tell me “I never thought I could play too much golf.” Here is an exercise I use with clients to help them visualize the next phase of their lives.

Filling in the Week

Start with the time you currently spend at the business. Include that “quiet time” at the beginning or end of the day when you like to think. Add in answering emails and texts at home or reading reports and articles on the weekend. Let’s say, conservatively, that you are engaged with your business for 50 hours a week.

Now, let’s start retirement with golf every Monday, Wednesday, and Friday. That’s a lot of golf, but we have only consumed about 15 hours of your workweek. What else?

Many folks will say they want to do more community service. Unless you plan to take on the full-time responsibility of running a charitable organization, let’s try simple volunteering to start. Two half-days a week? That’s another ten hours. We are up to twenty-five.

Travel is a big goal. How do four, two-week trips a year sound? That’s an average of another 8 hours a week.

Now you have two months of traveling, 150 golf outings, and 100 days a year working for charity. That only leaves you with about 17 hours a week to fill. Sleep in, exercise more, catch up on your reading?

There are lots of ways to fill the remaining time, but remember we are starting with someone who has a lot of plans. Many business owners have none.

Unhappy Exits

According to a survey by the Exit Planning Institute, up to 75% of former business owners are unhappy with their exits one year after selling.

I don’t know of any of my clients who are unhappy with the results. Perhaps that’s just luck, but I like to think it’s at least partially due to my coaching skill. The technical and financial complexities of a successful transition are nothing to sneeze at, but helping an owner be prepared is so much more than that.
Invest 15 Minutes and take our FREE Exit Readiness Assessment. We do not request any confidential information.

John F. Dini develops transition and succession strategies that allow business owners to exit their companies on their own schedule, with the proceeds they seek and complete control over the process. He takes a coaching approach to client engagements, focusing on helping owners of companies with $1M to $250M in revenue achieve both their desired lifestyles and legacies.

The Dismal Ds and Exit Planning

by

The “Dismal Ds” is an inside joke in exit planning. Every industry and profession has them. In some, it’s “You can have it done well, done fast, or done cheaply. Pick any two.” In planning it’s “Sooner or later, every owner exits his or her business… 100% guaranteed.”

Clearly, that refers to the unplanned but inevitable departure from the biggest D – Death. That isn’t the only D, however. There are others, NONE of which lead to a controlled, lucrative, or enjoyable transition. Most start with dis- defined as “dis– 1. a Latin prefix meaning “apart,” “asunder,” “away,” “utterly,” or having a privative, negative, or reversing force.”

The other Dismal Ds include:

  • Disease – the critical illness of the owner or an irreplaceable employee.
  • Dissension – between partners, shareholders, or family members
  • Disaster – Fire, flood, storm, or accident
  • Disability – An owner’s inability to oversee operations
  • Disinterest – of the founder or next-generation ownership
  • Distraction – When an owner’s focus is elsewhere. (frequently love or bar ownership)
  • Disarray – More simply, bad management
  • Dishonor – financial fraud or other skulduggery
  • Disenchantment – A fancy word for burnout
  • Divorce – a bitter fight over the business asset or its value
  • Debt – Leverage taken on in good times but no longer sustainable
  • Depression – Economic malaise (think hospitality in 2020.)
  • Defection– The poaching or bolting of a key employee, frequently in sales
  • Defenestration – Getting thrown from a window

(Okay, I may have gone too far with that last one, but I couldn’t resist.)

Planning – The Cure for the Dismal Ds

The point is, there are many ways of a forced exit from your business due to circumstances. Some might be beyond your control, but most can be avoided.

  • Disease – Have solid business continuity instructions in place
  • Dissension – Start with a good buy/sell or shareholders’ agreement that makes it plain how disagreements will be handled
  • Disaster – Fire, flood, storm, or accidents can be insured, including for loss of revenue.
  • Disability – Business continuity instructions again
  • Disinterest – Start implementing an exit plan before your business shows the effect. For example, in brokerage, we used to say “Show me an owner who says he is burned out, and I’ll show you financial statements that evidenced the problem three years ago.”
  • Distraction – Don’t buy a bar. Don’t buy another business. Don’t have an affair.
  • Disarray – Get help. Consulting, coaching and peer groups all work.
  • Dishonor – Have an outside party check your systems and security.
  • Disenchantment – See Disinterest
  • Divorce – Settle the value of the business first, preferably before the lawyers do it for you.
  • Debt – Limit your debt to half what your current cash flow can service.
  • Depression – If you have to cut expenses, do so deeply and quickly.
  • Defection– Two words- employment agreements
  • Defenestration – Stay away from the Departed, or Irish, Italian, and Jewish mobsters in general. Alternatively, live where there are only low-rise buildings.

Dismal DsI obviously have my tongue firmly planted in cheek for this column, but my point should be clear. Your business is probably the most valuable asset in your life. Losing it to unplanned events hurts. So even if you are no longer in the picture, you have some responsibility to your family, employees and customers.

A good exit plan, whether it’s for implementation now or years down the road, should take many, if not all of the Dismal Ds into account. All entrepreneurs want control over their future. That is why they are entrepreneurs. Planning isn’t merely an intellectual exercise. It’s all about control.

John F. Dini, CExP, CEPA is an exit planning coach and the President of MPN Incorporated in San Antonio Texas. He is the author of Your Exit Map: Navigating the Boomer Bust, and two other books on business ownership. If you want to see how prepared you are for transition, take the 15-minute Assessment at MPNInc.com/ExitMap.