Exit Planning Tools for Business Owners

employee performance

Is Your Business Built on Individual Heroics?

by

Great employees are a wonderful gift, but individual heroics aren’t healthy for your business.

Someday, you will start thinking about leaving the business. Perhaps you already do. When you begin planning for your transition, what will your company systems sound like when you describe them to a critical buyer?

“Yes, we have a process for that. It hasn’t been updated, but Martha knows it like the back of her hand.”

“We really don’t have anyone cross-trained on that machine. Bucky likes to work alone, but it’s okay because he hasn’t taken a vacation in three years.”

“We always use Andy on that route. There are lots of traffic snarls, and he’s the only one who seems to be able to finish on schedule.”

You are getting the point. When an employee is especially productive or reliable, it’s easy to become dependent on his or her individual heroics. It’s one fewer function of the business that you have to watch.

heroic workersIt is ironic that the very behaviors that make your life easier appear to be threats in the eyes of a prospective buyer. You know that they could pose a problem, but they haven’t so far. Why fiddle with what’s working?

The answer is because individual heroics discount the value of your business. A buyer worries that key workers might not like his or her management style. As a new owner, he might be immediately approached for pay increases. Worst of all, if one of your heroes’ performance heads south, he may not be able to fix it, or even know what is happening.

For just a moment, look at your best employees as threats. Do you have a contingency plan for each? Can Martha’s process be documented so anyone can do it? Is Bucky just a loner, or is he trying to make himself irreplaceable? Can Andy’s mental map be duplicated by routing software?

And in case you didn’t realize it, “I can do any of those jobs myself. ” is the worst of all possible answers. Those kind of individual heroics will send the buyer towards the exit instead of you.

Dependable high performers are invaluable, but they are frequently protective of their status. Recognize them, but make it plain that that their work needs to be duplicable. (Although, “Of course, not at the level you perform.”)

If you don’t, start looking at them as liabilities rather than assets.

Do you know a business owner who would enjoy Awake at 2 o’clock? Please share!

Selling to Employees: Is Your Exit Strategy Right in Front of You?

by

When I interview a prospective client for exit planning assistance, we usually explore selling to employees. The first reaction is always “That won’t work. They don’t have any money.”

If you have a company with reasonable cash flow, a talented management team and sufficient time, selling to employees is not only a realistic option; it may be the best way to get value from your business. I’ll define those parameters for you in a minute.

If you haven’t read my eBook Beating the Boomer Bust, follow the link for the free download. My research shows that the hard numbers will inevitably translate into a hard market. There are 3,000,000 Baby Boomers (over 50) who own businesses with employees. Over the next 20 years, that’s an average of 150,000 owner retirements per year. Intermediaries (brokers, private equity and M&A) account for about 9,000 transactions a year.

That leaves a lot of folks looking for a way to cash out. Selling to employees is a process that lets you keep control until retirement. By structuring the sale correctly, you can leave with the proceeds in the bank, not in a promissory note.

How does that work? It requires a bit of mental gymnastics. First, any owner has to accept that the only source of funding for any transaction is the cash flow of his or her company. If a buyer pays cash, he expects that cash flow to pay him back. If a bank finances the acquisition, they expect the cash flow to service the debt. If you finance it, you are the essentially the bank.

Selling to employees is the same. You use the current cash flow to help employees buy stock. In return, they qualify by working to increase the value of the business until your final return is equal to (or more than) what it was when you started.

Think of it as taking a note for 30% of the purchase price while you are still in control, so that you can get a 70% cash down payment when you leave.

Now, let’s discuss the parameters.

Cash Flow: Your company has to be earning more than just your paycheck. My rule of thumb is that around $500,000 a year after owner’s compensation gives enough to work with. More than that doesn’t change much, since then we are usually looking at a higher purchase price. Less than that is doable in a longer time frame, or if the owner is willing to subordinate some debt to the bank.

Management Team: You need at least one decision maker who does more than just go through the operational motions. Any third-party lender wants to be comfortable with company leadership when you’re gone. A large portion of our planning surrounds transfer and documentation of management capability sufficient to satisfy a lender.

Time Frame: Many business owners tell me “I’ll think about exiting in five years.” That’s fine, if your plan is to retire in fifteen years. Generally speaking, the longer you have, the more lucrative an internal sale can be. I’ve done three year plans, but five is much more comfortable, eight years is even better, and we regularly work on transitions of ten years and longer.

all for one one for allSelling to employees requires legal agreements, specialized compensation plans and a willingness to run the company transparently. The return is a team that is committed to the long term, highly motivated, and all on the same page when it comes to growing the business.

Why should you consider selling to employees?  Because your company lives on with the culture you created. Because you can choose the value, not negotiate it. Because your employees aren’t comparing your company with other investments. Because you control the timing of your exit.

Because it is probably the biggest financial transaction of your life.

Do you know an owner who would benefit from reading Awake at 2 o’clock? Please share!

The 7 Deadly Sins of an Entrepreneur — Reprise

by

I make no claim that using the Seven Deadly Sins as a metaphor for business behavior is original. Of course, the original concept is a codifying of “undesirable” human behaviors, or sins. The work probably comes from the Latin word sons (guilty). Various sources attribute it to Old English and Hebrew, but since Latin was the language of the church, this seems most likely.

The concept of personifying the seven sins for popular consumption, as I mentioned in the first column in this series, goes back at least to Dante in the early 1300’s. It’s been used regularly in popular fiction including Roald Dahl’s Charlie and the Chocolate Factory (the five golden ticket winners each represent a sin, with Grandpa as Envy and Willie Wonka as Wrath); and in “Sponge Bob Squarepants” (I’ll assume that most readers don’t know the characters well enough to make identification worthwhile.)

gilligans-titlePerhaps the most amusing application was in “Gilligan’s Island.” The seven castaways fill their assignments well. There’s Gilligan (Sloth), the Skipper too (Wrath).  The millionaire (Thurston Howell — Greed) and his wife (Gluttony). The movie star (Ginger — Lust, of course); The professor (Pride) and Mary Ann (Envy), here on Gilligan’s Isle (Hell?)

My apologies if I just stuck that tune in your head for the rest of the day.

When I present “The 7 Sins of an Entrepreneur” to business audiences, they take special delight in identifying their own behaviors. Maybe it’s because they are relieved (“Gee, I only have four.”) or because they are naturally competitive (“Hey, I hit on all seven!”)

What ever the reason, it’s an easy way to organize negative behaviors. Perhaps that’s why it has remained so dominant a concept. Regardless of your failings, they can probably be categorized as one of the seven sins.

Here is a synopsis in order, with the corresponding “virtues” that counteract each.

  • The Operational Sins: Those which reduce your personal effectiveness as an owner and leader.
    • Lust: Allowing whim du jour to drag the company in differing directions. (Counteracting behavior: A Personal Vision.)
    • Gluttony: Hoarding all authority and decision-making for yourself. (Delegation)
  • The Tactical Sins: Those which denigrate the effectiveness of your organization.
    • Sloth: Settling for “good enough.” (Metrics and Benchmarking)
    • Wrath: Using adrenaline to drive performance. (Planning)
    • Greed: Addressing any problem with more effort or more intensity. (Budgeting)
  • The Strategic Sins: Those that prevent long term vision and improvement.
    • Envy: Thinking that no one else has your problems. (Outside advice and knowledge)
    • Pride: Believing that you are the single most important factor in your company. (Exit Strategy)

The sins are addressed in order. Dealing with the Operational Sins allows you to tackle the Tactical problems. Strategic improvement is only possible if you’ve first dealt with Tactical issues.

The Seven Deadly Sins of an Entrepreneur are an excellent mnemonic for considering your own behavior and those of your company.  Keep them in mind as you run your business day-to-day.

If you enjoy “Awake at 2 o’clock,” please share it with other business owners. Thanks for reading!

The Seventh Entrepreneurial Sin — Pride

by

Every business owner should be proud of his or her business. If you are the founder, you built every system, and probably landed the biggest customers. If you bought the business, you took what was in place and made it fit your vision and style.

But there is a dividing line between pride in what you’ve created and thinking that you are the business. Taking pleasure in seeing people add value and produce wealth is justifiable pride. Thinking that it exists only because of you is “sinful” pride.

(This is the eighth in a series on The Seven Deadly Sins of an Entrepreneur. It starts here.)

pawn to kingPride has characteristics that are easily recognizable in some owners. In meetings, do you do all the talking? Do you complain that you are the only one who has new ideas? Does everyone come to you for the solutions to any and every problem? Worse yet, do you insist on it? Do you reprimand employees for making decisions that, while they might work, aren’t exactly the way you would have done it?

My friend Kevin Armstrong in Vancouver says “The more you work in your business, the less it is worth.” Building an organization that is dependent on you to operate it has one drawback.

You can’t leave…ever. If you are the business, then it is worth nothing without you.

In the worst cases, you can’t take a vacation. Even getting away for a few days requires that you be tethered to electronic communications. Perhaps you’ve built sufficient managerial capacity to keep things going for a few weeks, but upon your return you have to jump-start activity again.

Here’s another axiom, this one from John Brown of the Business Enterprise Institute in Golden, Colorado. “Sooner or later, every business owner leaves his or her business.” In stark terms, you can think about how you want to exit, or you can let it be a surprise.

The virtue that counteracts Pride is Exit Planning. An exit plan differs greatly with the owner’s age, his or her personal goals and the size of the business. In every case, it requires consideration of finances, career objectives, lifestyle ambitions, management development and self-maintaining systems.

Ah, but you are still young. You are still healthy. You still enjoy running the business. Why would you want to think about leaving?

Because thinking about how the business will function without you leads to greater profitability, a higher value for your company, and more personal flexibility in your life. Aren’t those reason enough?

Professional investors craft an exit strategy before they buy into a company. For most entrepreneurs, especially in their first five years, leaving is the furthest thing from their minds. If you are beyond your fifth anniversary as an owner, you should have one eye on the door, even if it’s still a long way off.

Thinking about the business as a separate entity, something that will survive after you’ve moved on, will help make you think in longer, more strategic terms about things like new products, target markets, and developing other decision makers in your organization. It brings up questions many owners ignore, especially “What does my company look like to a buyer?”

Long, long ago I was a manager for a national chain restaurant. They taught me a trick that I still use today. Once a week or so I’d walk out in front of my restaurant and stand with my back to it. I’d close my eyes and think “I am a new customer, who has never been to this establishment before. I’ve never even driven past. I am seeing it for the very first time.”

Then I’d turn around and look at my business for the very first time. I always saw something that could have been better.

Selling a business is a bit like selling a house. You spruce things up so that it looks good. In a business you make sure your financial statements are up to date and easily understood. You tighten up on expenses. You refresh operating procedures.

If you start seriously thinking about your exit now, you’ll naturally regard your business through your buyer’s eyes. To quote one of my own favorite axioms, “The things you should do to get the best price for your business are the same things you should do every day that you own it.”

Thanks for reading “Awake at 2 o’clock”. Please share it with other business owners.

The Sixth Entrepreneurial Sin — Envy

by

This week we start on the two remaining deadly sins of an entrepreneur. Envy and Pride are the strategic sins. The first two (Lust and Gluttony) are operational; they interfere with how you function as an owner and leader. The middle three, Sloth, Wrath and Greed, are tactical. They interfere with how you run your business.

The strategic sins twist your vision and goals for the business. The first of these, Envy, is defined in the dictionary as a feeling of discontent with regard to another’s advantages.

In our business owner peer groups, we ask new members after their first Board meeting what they took away from the experience. By far the most common answer is “I thought I was the only one experiencing problems in my business.” That’s envy, an unrealistic belief that the face other owners show to the world is entirely true, and that you are the only one facing challenges.

envy whyYou are guilty of Envy if you think everyone else has better employees than yours. If you believe that other owners are making more money, or have a better work/life balance than you, envy is a problem. The common envious phrase that I hear is “My problems are different. No one else has a business that’s as difficult as mine.”

It’s not true. I’ve consulted in hundreds of companies, and I have yet to see one that didn’t hit bumps in the road. Each has its own special challenges.

Take the construction trades for an example. The roofing repair contractors say “No one else is as weather dependent as we are. When it rains, we can’t work. When the sun shines, no one needs us.”

Electricians are the first on the job (to run power for everyone else) and the last to leave (installing face plates on a finished project.) The window contractors have to provide a finished (and fragile) product at an early stage of construction, but are expected to have it still look perfect after months of everyone else working around it.

I’ve heard each say that their issues are unique to their trade, which is true. They also say that no one else has challenges as great as theirs, which isn’t.

The business virtue that counters Envy is Knowledge. Knowledge is a three-legged stool. You need financial knowledge, legal knowledge and business knowledge to succeed in business.

Financial knowledge grows out of meeting with your accountant and banker more than once a year. They can provide a lot of insight into your business if you ask the right questions. How are others in my industry faring in this market? What metrics do you use when judging the credit worthiness of companies like mine?

Legal knowledge comes from talking to an attorney when issues are small, not just when you are afraid of a lawsuit. Do I need a contract for this? What will my possible liability be in this situation? Are there regulations or laws I need to be aware of?

Most business owners acknowledge that they need legal and financial advice. The biggest remedy for Envy, however, lies in the third leg of the stool — business advice. Accountants and lawyers aren’t typically entrepreneurs. Good business advice comes from business people.

There are lots of places to find business advice. Your trade group or professional association is the first place to look. There you’ll find others who deal with exactly what you face. The business departments of local colleges, the Service Core of Retired Executives (SCORE) and Small Business Development Centers (SBDC), both sponsored by the SBA, offer free counseling in most cities.

After five years as a member of peer groups and another two decades facilitating them, I admit to a prejudice in favor of getting business advice from other business owners. There is nothing more valid than real-life experience from folks who have “Been there — Done that — Have the tee shirt.”

Eighty percent of running a business is common to all businesses. We all deal with employee compensation and incentives, new technology, changing market conditions, competitors, regulations, vendors and customers. The other 20%, the part that generates revenue, is all that is uniquely yours.

If you don’t have a safe and confidential place to discuss your business with others who face the same issues, find one. It’s the only cure for Envy.

Thanks for reading Awake at 2 o’clock? Please share it with other business owners.